Ally has drawn some conclusions that must be the result of being eleven years old with a budding understanding of how the world works while still believing in Santa Claus.
Yesterday we were talking about Christmas and the twins wondered if Santa would bring presents for all the animals. Then Ally said, "No, that's Saint Nick's thing, not Santa's." After a moment, she continued, "...because he's government funded."
This reminded me of a comment she'd made when opening her stocking. I hadn't had a chance to revisit it that morning, because things were crazy, and I'd forgotten to circle back. But we had time now.
"How do you mean?" I asked.
Ally explained, "You know. He gets his money from the government."
Nope, that didn't clear it up. So I waited for her to continue.
"Because he buys things in stores, rather than having elves make them. He brings regular store things. So, it must come from taxpayer's money."
Got it!!!
Suddenly what she said opening her stockings also made sense. She'd commented, "The whole St. Nick thing is really unfair to Jews. They pay taxes, too, but don't benefit from the St. Nick thing."
I worry she is going to be so angry when the whole Santa thing comes to light. It's such a difficult balancing act. I'd had the talk way too early with Kate, not wanting her to feel lied to, but she was so sad to know. So I held off with Anna. Anna figured it out naturally, and she let me know last year that she was only going along with it for my sake. So, I was hoping things would go like that for Ally and Luke, but I also don't want them to be teased at school or feel betrayed that I lied to them.
So, a few weeks ago, I'd asked Ally, "So what do you think about the whole Santa thing?"
She'd responded definitively, "Oh, he's real!" She listed several reasons why, concluding with, "And remember the way the ping pong table was set up a couple years ago. There's no way you and Daddy could have pulled that off."
So, her impression that Dave and I are completely inept solidified the Santa thing for her.